A   A   A

Posted: Tuesday, 23 October 2012 4:36AM

Arizona ballot measure contests ownership of the Grand Canyon



PHOENIX (Reuters) - When voters in Arizona go to the polls next month, they will be asked to decide a landownership tug of war: Should the Grand Canyon belong to all Americans, or just the residents of Arizona?

A controversial ballot measure backed by Republicans in the state legislature is seeking sovereign control over millions of acres of federal land in the state, including the Grand Canyon.

Proposition 120 would amend the state's constitution to declare Arizona's sovereignty and jurisdiction over the "air, water, public lands, minerals, wildlife and other natural resources within the state's boundaries."

The measure is the latest salvo in the so-called "sagebrush revolt" by Republicans in the West aiming to take back control of major swaths of land owned by various federal agencies, much of it by the Interior Department's Bureau of Land Management.

State Senator Sylvia Allen, one of the Republican backers of the measure, argues that federal retention of the land hurts the economy of the Western states and leaves them struggling to fund public education, nurture their economies, and manage their forests and natural resources.

"We do not have the ability in rural Arizona to provide jobs for our citizens due to the fact that the federal government controls all the land," Allen told Reuters. "It leaves us at a great disadvantage. We're not able to bring in industry and provide for the jobs that we need," she added.

The exact area of public land targeted by the measure - which excludes American Indian reservations and federal installations such as arsenals - was not immediately clear on the Arizona Secretary of State's website.

The Sierra Club pegged the area at between 39,000 and 46,700 square miles (101,000 and 121,000 square km) - or 34 percent to 41 percent of the entire state.

BATTLE OVER LAND

The ballot measure is just the latest move in a decades-old federal-state skirmish over control of a wide range of natural resources in Western states, often pitting mining, drilling and logging companies against those seeking to protect the environment.

The efforts have had mixed success. In May, Arizona's Republican Governor Jan Brewer vetoed a state bill calling on Washington to relinquish the title to 48,000 square miles (124,000 square km), arguing that it created uncertainty for existing leaseholders on federal lands in difficult economic times.

But similar legislation was signed into law by Governor Gary Herbert in neighboring Utah in March, despite warnings from state attorneys that it was likely unconstitutional and would trigger a costly and ultimately futile legal battle.

Opponents of the latest drive to assert Arizona's ownership say that, if successful, the initiative could undermine protections provided by federal environmental laws such as the Clean Air Act, Endangered Species Act, and Clean Water Act, and would saddle Arizona with lands for which it would be unable to care.

"They can't even fund and ensure that their (state) parks are protected, so how they would take on an additional 25 to 30 million acres of land is a big question mark," Sandy Bahr, director of the Sierra Club Grand Canyon Chapter, told Reuters.

No polls have given a sense of whether Prop 120 will prosper during the November 6 election. But Bahr cautioned that, should it pass, it would inevitably trigger fresh litigation for Arizona, which recently fought a legal battle over its tough 2010 crackdown on illegal immigrants all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court.

"This one is just blatantly unconstitutional," Bahr said of Prop 120. "Does Arizona really need another lawsuit?"

Story & Photos Copyright 2012 Reuters
Filed Under :  
Topics : Politics
Social :
Locations : ArizonaPhoenixUtahWashington
People : Gary HerbertJan BrewerSandy BahrSylvia Allen

Tornado insured losses estimates top $5 billion


Tornadoes that struck from May 18 to May 20 caused between $2 billion to $5 billion in losses.

Arizona jury fails to decide if Jodi Arias should be executed


An Arizona jury failed to reach a unanimous verdict on whether Jodi Arias should be put to death.

IRS official at center of scandal put on leave


Lois Lerner, an IRS official at the center of the scandal, was put on administrative leave.

Obama limits drone use, looks to close Guantanamo


President Obama outlined plans to limit the use of drones and took steps aimed at closing Guantanamo.

British police arrest two more over London attack


British police arrested two more people in a hunt for accomplices.

Father of Chechen shot by FBI suspects son was tortured


The father of the Chechen immigrant killed during questioning said he suspects his son was tortured.

Boy Scouts of America removes ban on gay scouts


The Boy Scouts of America approved a proposal to end a ban on openly gay scouts.

Rep. Issa to call IRS's Lerner back to testify


Rep. Darrell Issa said he will call IRS official Lois Lerner back to testify.

Oklahoma tornado victims astounded at how they survived


Tornado survivors thanked God, sturdy closets and luck.

Military lawyers put more pressure on Guantanamo


Military lawyers urged Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel to improve conditions for detainees.

Drones have killed 4 U.S. citizens


Public backlash against deadly overseas drone strikes may undermine promising uses of such technology.

IRS official refuses to answer questions at hearing


An IRS official told Congress she had done nothing wrong but would not answer questions.

FBI agent shoots man questioned about Boston bombings


An FBI agent shot and killed a Florida man who turned violent while being questioned.

Rescuers comb tornado rubble for buried survivors


Rescue workers with sniffer dogs and searchlights combed through the wreckage.

Senate committee passes immigration bill


A Senate panel approved legislation to give millions of illegal immigrants a path to citizenship.